Posted by Dave on Nov 23, 2016; 4:38pm
URL: https://forum.idpguru.com/Help-me-with-a-good-league-setup-tp4028504p4028518.html

Ynot - I've played IDP only since 1990 and don't believe you ever will find what you seek regardless of scoring system. IDP is one of those things that you either like or you don't. I think that Chris Conley is right, unless you want it to be a 50/50 proposition, you shouldn't try it.

It IS entirely unpredictable and despite you "seeing Player X make a tackle", it rarely shows up immediately in the stats, if at all! Generally speaking, once a hardcore fantasy player plays in a good IDP league, they will never want to go back to "fake" (i.e. - offense only) league. Many DO find IDP too complicated, boring, and frustrating, I absolutely get that.

I recommend you find a good 50/50 league and invest a season in it. I doubt you'll return to what you've always played ... GOOD LUCK!