Toler vs Newman

Who should be a better pick up for this week vs rest of the season?

Toler (vs Stl, Den, Car, Dal)
Newman (vs Ind, Phi, Was, Ari)

I could add Greer to this mix

Greer (vs Cin, Stl, Bal, Atl)

I don't trust Toler. I would go with Newman this week and Greer ROS after that.